Friday, October 9, 2026

“There's not a Black America and White America and Latino America and Asian America; there's the United States of America.”

By Yiannis Damellos and Mars Strangelove Jr.

October 9, 2026

Obama said it in 2004. Two decades later, Abdul El-Sayed is fighting for the Senate in a country increasingly encouraged to see its neighbors as enemies. Michigan will test whether a politics of common interests can survive the politics of division. 

There are political speeches that disappear into the noise of an election, and there are sentences that wait patiently for history to make them relevant again. In 2004, Barack Obama told the Democratic National Convention: “There's not a liberal America and a conservative America; there's the United States of America.” He continued: “There's not a Black America and White America and Latino America and Asian America; there's the United States of America.” It was a declaration of national solidarity, not a claim that Americans had no differences. Obama was arguing that differences did not have to become permanent barriers between people. More than two decades later, those words sound less like a celebration of an accomplished ideal than a challenge to a country struggling to remember it.

In Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed has become one of the faces of that struggle. The progressive Democrat won a tightly contested primary against Representative Haley Stevens and is now challenging Republican Mike Rogers for a seat in the U.S. Senate. A public-health administrator with a medical degree from Columbia University and a doctorate from Oxford, El-Sayed has built his campaign around universal health care, taxing billionaires, reducing corporate influence and changing America's approach to foreign military assistance. He has received support from progressive figures including Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. His politics are unapologetically left-wing, but his central economic argument is not confined to one ideological tribe: ordinary Americans should not have to accept insecurity while those with the greatest wealth and influence enjoy the greatest protection.

That argument matters in a state where economic interests cross the boundaries of race, religion and party. Michigan is home to major manufacturing industries, union households, rural communities, struggling urban neighborhoods and one of the country's most visible Arab American populations. People in these communities may disagree profoundly about immigration, religion, foreign policy and the role of government. They nevertheless confront overlapping questions: Can a family afford housing? Can a worker pay medical bills? Can a young person expect a better life than their parents? And can elected officials be trusted to serve the public rather than the donors who finance their campaigns? El-Sayed's challenge is to make those shared questions more powerful than the forces pulling voters apart.

The Republican response has already demonstrated how difficult that task will be. On October 8, Donald Trump attacked El-Sayed on social media, calling him a “RADICAL Extremist” and a “Terrorist Sympathizer.” El-Sayed's positions on Israel and Gaza have made him a target of fierce criticism, particularly his description of Israel's actions in Gaza as genocide and his opposition to unconditional U.S. military aid. These are contentious political and legal questions, and voters are entitled to examine his statements and policies critically. But there is a difference between challenging a candidate's record and using inflammatory labels to define him before the public has considered his arguments. The same democratic standard must apply to every candidate, regardless of religion or ancestry: judge the policies, examine the evidence and debate the substance.

El-Sayed, meanwhile, cannot build a broad coalition simply by accusing Republicans of division. He must persuade voters who do not share his views on every issue that his economic program would improve their lives. He must also address the concerns of voters who question his foreign-policy positions, including people who see Israel as an essential American ally or who fear that criticism of Israeli policy can spill into hostility toward Jewish communities. A politics of unity cannot mean demanding silence from one side or dismissing the anxieties of another. It must mean that disagreement remains possible without turning fellow citizens into enemies. That is a more demanding undertaking than delivering a speech, but it is also the test of political leadership.

The timing of Barack Obama's planned appearance with El-Sayed in Detroit on October 24 is therefore significant. Obama remains associated with a political language that sought to build a national majority across racial and ideological lines. His decision to campaign for El-Sayed also puts the former president alongside a progressive candidate whose positions on health care, wealth and the Middle East are not universally embraced within the Democratic establishment. The symbolism is useful, but it cannot do the work for the candidate. El-Sayed must connect the promise of economic fairness to the daily experiences of voters who may distrust his party, disagree with him on foreign policy or simply want to know whether Washington will make their lives more affordable.

There is a lesson here for both American parties. A country cannot solve its problems if every economic grievance is converted into a cultural war, every disagreement into a loyalty test and every election into a contest over which group deserves to be feared. Nor can national unity be manufactured by asking disadvantaged communities to forget discrimination or asking workers to ignore widening economic inequalities. The point of Obama's words was not that America had already overcome its divisions. It was that the country shared a responsibility to overcome them. Unity without justice becomes a slogan; justice without a willingness to share a country becomes another battlefield.

Michigan's Senate contest will not, by itself, settle the argument over America's future. But it offers a clear question for voters and candidates alike: can a campaign built around common economic interests persuade people to look beyond the identities that political operatives use to sort them into opposing camps? El-Sayed must earn that trust through his proposals, his conduct and his ability to answer difficult questions. Rogers must be judged by the same standard. And Trump, whose rhetoric has helped intensify the personal and cultural dimensions of this contest, should not be allowed to replace policy debate with name-calling.

Obama's words were never a promise that Americans would agree. They were a reminder that disagreement does not erase citizenship, and that a person's race, religion or political beliefs do not determine the worth of their voice. The United States does not become stronger by pretending its divisions do not exist. It becomes stronger when its people refuse to let those divisions define the limits of their common future.

There is a liberal America and a conservative America in the sense that Americans hold different beliefs. There are Black, White, Latino, Asian, Arab American and many other communities with distinct histories and experiences. But there is only one country in which they must work out their future together. The question is whether its leaders will help them do that — or keep teaching them to fear one another.

No comments:

Post a Comment