There was little progress on nuclear arms control, no breakthrough on Ukraine, and no major diplomatic achievement to announce. But Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping apparently found something they could agree on in Shenzhen: a world with fewer restrictions on those who already possess the greatest power.
The trilateral meeting in China may ultimately be remembered less for what the three presidents accomplished than for what they appear determined to dismantle. According to The Washington Post, their common ground lies in weakening the international institutions and mechanisms established after World War II to prevent powerful nations from imposing their will without consequences.
Their 226-word joint declaration was brief. Its implications could be considerably larger.
The three leaders pledged cooperation on reforming the United Nations, increasing the production and supply of refined petroleum products, and limiting the reach of the International Criminal Court (ICC). The latter has issued an arrest warrant for Putin over alleged war crimes in Ukraine.
They also took aim at energy sanctions imposed against Russia following its invasion of Ukraine, restrictions that have complicated Moscow's ability to sell its oil internationally.
In other words, while the three governments have vastly different interests, they appear to share a particularly convenient preference: fewer international obstacles to exercising their power.
The Postwar Order Is the Target
The international architecture established after 1945 was far from perfect. The United States, in particular, has repeatedly demonstrated that it is willing to bypass international rules when its own interests demand it. The United Nations has also struggled to prevent wars, atrocities and violations of international law.
But those institutions were created for a reason. After two devastating world wars, their architects sought to replace military confrontation with diplomacy, make territorial expansion through force more difficult, and give smaller nations a voice in decisions traditionally dominated by the great powers.
That imperfect system is now facing an unusual challenge: three presidents from countries with competing geopolitical ambitions appear willing to cooperate in weakening some of its fundamental safeguards.
Ned Price, a former senior diplomat in the Biden administration, described the message behind the declaration as an attempt to discard the rules that have governed the international system for eight decades and replace them with something fundamentally different.
The distinction is not merely diplomatic. It concerns the question of whether international rules should apply to powerful nations as well as everyone else.
The international architecture established after 1945 was far from perfect. The United States, in particular, has repeatedly demonstrated that it is willing to bypass international rules when its own interests demand it. The United Nations has also struggled to prevent wars, atrocities and violations of international law.
But those institutions were created for a reason. After two devastating world wars, their architects sought to replace military confrontation with diplomacy, make territorial expansion through force more difficult, and give smaller nations a voice in decisions traditionally dominated by the great powers.
That imperfect system is now facing an unusual challenge: three presidents from countries with competing geopolitical ambitions appear willing to cooperate in weakening some of its fundamental safeguards.
Ned Price, a former senior diplomat in the Biden administration, described the message behind the declaration as an attempt to discard the rules that have governed the international system for eight decades and replace them with something fundamentally different.
The distinction is not merely diplomatic. It concerns the question of whether international rules should apply to powerful nations as well as everyone else.
Trump's Uncomfortable Alignment
Previous American presidents have called for reforms at the United Nations and the International Criminal Court. But, as Price pointed out, they did not join forces with traditional American adversaries to pursue those changes.
Trump has taken a different approach.
He praised Putin and Xi, calling both men friends, and described his China trip as a great journey of tremendous significance. He also thanked Beijing for bringing the three leaders together.
The symbolism was difficult to miss. The president of the United States, traditionally the leading power within the Western democratic alliance, was publicly celebrating his political chemistry with the leaders of Russia and China.
Trump's complaints about international institutions have also been particularly pronounced when they have challenged the interests of governments he supports. His administration has accused the UN and the ICC of bias against Israel, while arguing that the latter has exceeded its mandate.
The Russian dimension is equally revealing. Trump has repeatedly criticized Ukrainian attacks on Russian oil refineries and, according to the report, reportedly reached an arrangement with Putin last month involving the purchase of Russian diesel despite American sanctions.
He has also blamed Zelensky for actions he claims have increased fuel prices for American consumers. Energy analysts, however, attribute a much larger share of the increase since February to Trump's war in Iran.
Previous American presidents have called for reforms at the United Nations and the International Criminal Court. But, as Price pointed out, they did not join forces with traditional American adversaries to pursue those changes.
Trump has taken a different approach.
He praised Putin and Xi, calling both men friends, and described his China trip as a great journey of tremendous significance. He also thanked Beijing for bringing the three leaders together.
The symbolism was difficult to miss. The president of the United States, traditionally the leading power within the Western democratic alliance, was publicly celebrating his political chemistry with the leaders of Russia and China.
Trump's complaints about international institutions have also been particularly pronounced when they have challenged the interests of governments he supports. His administration has accused the UN and the ICC of bias against Israel, while arguing that the latter has exceeded its mandate.
The Russian dimension is equally revealing. Trump has repeatedly criticized Ukrainian attacks on Russian oil refineries and, according to the report, reportedly reached an arrangement with Putin last month involving the purchase of Russian diesel despite American sanctions.
He has also blamed Zelensky for actions he claims have increased fuel prices for American consumers. Energy analysts, however, attribute a much larger share of the increase since February to Trump's war in Iran.
Ukraine: Peace, or Another Bill for Europe?
On his return flight to Washington, Trump contacted European leaders gathered in Berlin with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
His message was that Putin wanted peace.
Trump reportedly suggested that ending the war would allow European countries to redirect the resources currently being spent supporting Ukraine toward their own domestic needs.
It was a familiar argument, but its timing was significant. The conversation came immediately after Trump's meeting with Putin and Xi, while European leaders were discussing the future of a war that directly concerns European security.
The contrast between the two gatherings was striking.
In Shenzhen, three powerful leaders sat around one table, with Xi presiding, Trump on his left and Putin on his right. In Berlin, dozens of European leaders and Zelensky met in a political environment shaped by voters, parliaments, competing interests and democratic accountability.
The difference goes beyond diplomatic style. It reflects two fundamentally different approaches to political authority.
As the article observes, authoritarian leaders can often make decisions with considerably fewer domestic obstacles. Democratic leaders must negotiate, explain and answer to institutions and citizens.
On his return flight to Washington, Trump contacted European leaders gathered in Berlin with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.
His message was that Putin wanted peace.
Trump reportedly suggested that ending the war would allow European countries to redirect the resources currently being spent supporting Ukraine toward their own domestic needs.
It was a familiar argument, but its timing was significant. The conversation came immediately after Trump's meeting with Putin and Xi, while European leaders were discussing the future of a war that directly concerns European security.
The contrast between the two gatherings was striking.
In Shenzhen, three powerful leaders sat around one table, with Xi presiding, Trump on his left and Putin on his right. In Berlin, dozens of European leaders and Zelensky met in a political environment shaped by voters, parliaments, competing interests and democratic accountability.
The difference goes beyond diplomatic style. It reflects two fundamentally different approaches to political authority.
As the article observes, authoritarian leaders can often make decisions with considerably fewer domestic obstacles. Democratic leaders must negotiate, explain and answer to institutions and citizens.
The Damage May Outlast Trump
Trump may have limited time to reshape the international system. His domestic political position has weakened following the midterm elections, and the new Congress, taking office in January, is expected to provide stronger opposition and potentially launch investigations into the administration.
But foreign policy offers presidents considerable room to manoeuvre. Congressional opposition may complicate Trump's domestic agenda without necessarily reversing the diplomatic relationships he is building.
Price warned that the damage could be more permanent than any individual policy decision.
The United States, he argued, is creating the impression that it can align itself with governments promoting an illiberal vision of the world — one fundamentally opposed to the democratic principles Washington has traditionally claimed to defend.
A future American president may reverse particular decisions. Rebuilding international confidence, however, is another matter.
As Price noted, no successor will be able to erase the image of Trump standing alongside Putin and Xi or undo the political message carried by their joint declaration.
Trump may have limited time to reshape the international system. His domestic political position has weakened following the midterm elections, and the new Congress, taking office in January, is expected to provide stronger opposition and potentially launch investigations into the administration.
But foreign policy offers presidents considerable room to manoeuvre. Congressional opposition may complicate Trump's domestic agenda without necessarily reversing the diplomatic relationships he is building.
Price warned that the damage could be more permanent than any individual policy decision.
The United States, he argued, is creating the impression that it can align itself with governments promoting an illiberal vision of the world — one fundamentally opposed to the democratic principles Washington has traditionally claimed to defend.
A future American president may reverse particular decisions. Rebuilding international confidence, however, is another matter.
As Price noted, no successor will be able to erase the image of Trump standing alongside Putin and Xi or undo the political message carried by their joint declaration.
Europe Has a Problem — and Trump Knows It
Trump has repeatedly expressed surprise that he appears to have better personal relations with Putin and Xi than with European leaders.
Wolfgang Ischinger, the former German ambassador to Washington and current chairman of the Munich Security Conference, offered an explanation: Trump places enormous importance on personal relationships, and Europe does not have a single leader with the concentrated authority of Xi Jinping.
But that observation exposes another weakness in the argument for personal diplomacy.
Europe is not designed to operate like China or Russia. Its leadership is divided among governments, institutions and elected representatives because democratic authority is distributed rather than concentrated in one individual.
That can make negotiations slower and more complicated. It also provides checks against the arbitrary exercise of power.
Julian Gewirtz, a former Biden administration official involved in China policy, captured the symbolism of the Shenzhen meeting: the three great powers were presenting themselves as equal partners at the same table, while everyone else remained outside, watching.
That is precisely the problem.
The international system was never supposed to be a private club in which three powerful men decide what rules everyone else should follow. Its purpose was to make sure that power, however great, did not become its own justification.
Trump, Putin and Xi may not agree on everything. They have competing interests, different ambitions and very different visions of their respective positions in the world.
But in Shenzhen, they found common ground in challenging the institutions that stand between national power and unrestricted political authority.
And while the three leaders were discussing a new international understanding, the rest of the world was left with a rather uncomfortable question:
If the most powerful countries decide that the rules no longer apply to them, who exactly is left to defend them?
Trump has repeatedly expressed surprise that he appears to have better personal relations with Putin and Xi than with European leaders.
Wolfgang Ischinger, the former German ambassador to Washington and current chairman of the Munich Security Conference, offered an explanation: Trump places enormous importance on personal relationships, and Europe does not have a single leader with the concentrated authority of Xi Jinping.
But that observation exposes another weakness in the argument for personal diplomacy.
Europe is not designed to operate like China or Russia. Its leadership is divided among governments, institutions and elected representatives because democratic authority is distributed rather than concentrated in one individual.
That can make negotiations slower and more complicated. It also provides checks against the arbitrary exercise of power.
Julian Gewirtz, a former Biden administration official involved in China policy, captured the symbolism of the Shenzhen meeting: the three great powers were presenting themselves as equal partners at the same table, while everyone else remained outside, watching.
That is precisely the problem.
The international system was never supposed to be a private club in which three powerful men decide what rules everyone else should follow. Its purpose was to make sure that power, however great, did not become its own justification.
Trump, Putin and Xi may not agree on everything. They have competing interests, different ambitions and very different visions of their respective positions in the world.
But in Shenzhen, they found common ground in challenging the institutions that stand between national power and unrestricted political authority.
And while the three leaders were discussing a new international understanding, the rest of the world was left with a rather uncomfortable question:
If the most powerful countries decide that the rules no longer apply to them, who exactly is left to defend them?


No comments:
Post a Comment