

Trump threatens to veto his way through Congress. But the Constitution has other ideas
November 20, 2026
By Mars Strangelove Jr.
Donald Trump appears to have discovered a new governing strategy: if Congress sends him legislation he doesn't like, he will veto it. And if lawmakers send another bill, he will veto that one too. He says the process can continue for the next two years and one month, apparently confident that the presidential veto will give him the upper hand in every confrontation with the legislative branch.Trump sees the presidential veto as his ultimate bargaining instrument. On November 20, he openly described his strategy: Democrats can send him legislation, he will veto it, and they can keep sending more until they understand that negotiations must take place on his terms. He predicted that after approximately a month, Democratic leaders Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer would begin seeking compromises. Both men, he observed, were "smart." Trump had already floated the same strategy in an earlier interview, suggesting he could spend the first month or two rejecting Democratic legislation before striking deals. In other words, he intends to turn a constitutional power designed to check legislation into a negotiating weapon against a Congress controlled by the opposition.It sounds less like a constitutional democracy and more like a presidential tantrum with an official stationery set. But there is a rather significant detail Trump seems to have overlooked: the United States Constitution does not give the president unlimited authority over the legislative branch. The president has veto power, certainly. He does not have ownership of Congress.Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution provides a direct answer to Trump's proposed legislative blockade. Congress can override a presidential veto if two-thirds of the members voting in both the House of Representatives and the Senate support the legislation, with a quorum present. Once that threshold is reached in both chambers, the bill becomes law without the president's signature. Trump can object, complain, threaten and reach for his veto pen again, but he cannot stop a constitutionally sufficient congressional majority.Of course, securing two-thirds of both chambers is difficult, particularly in a deeply polarized political environment. But the absence of an override majority does not leave Congress powerless. The legislative branch controls federal appropriations, conducts investigations, exercises oversight, confirms presidential appointments through the Senate and can compel testimony and documents through its committees, subject to applicable legal protections. Congress can also refuse to approve funding for presidential priorities. The president retains the power to veto appropriations bills, but that does not transfer the constitutional power of the purse to the White House. The ability to investigate, expose, negotiate and make funding decisions remains a formidable source of congressional leverage.THE OTHER FRONT: 50 STATES, AND NOT ONE PRESIDENTIAL VETOBut Washington is not the only place where the constitutional battle can be fought. The United States has fifty state governments, each with its own legislature, governor and constitutional responsibilities. And unlike Congress, state legislatures do not send their bills to the White House for presidential approval.Trump has no veto over legislation passed in California, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts or any other state. Within their constitutional authority, these states can continue enacting protections for healthcare, workers' rights, voting access, the environment and civil liberties, even when those policies run directly against the president's political agenda, provided they do not conflict with valid federal law.They can also challenge federal executive actions in court, coordinate legal challenges with other states and refuse to lend their own personnel and administrative machinery to federal enforcement programs where the Constitution does not permit Washington to compel their cooperation. This is not an invitation to disregard federal law. It is a constitutional boundary: Washington can enforce federal law through its own lawful authority, but it cannot simply commandeer state governments and their employees to do the federal government's work.Federal law remains supreme when constitutionally valid and applicable, but the president cannot simply command fifty state governments to become extensions of his administration. There is even a constitutional mechanism beyond his veto: under Article V, the legislatures of 34 states can apply to Congress to call a convention for proposing constitutional amendments. Any amendment emerging through that process would still require ratification by 38 states. It is a demanding process, not an overnight political shortcut, but it demonstrates that the Constitution provides a route for the states to participate in fundamental constitutional change without presidential approval.The political message is unmistakable: the American republic has more than one centre of power. If Trump wants to turn Washington into a presidential veto chamber, the states can become an alternative front for defending democratic institutions, individual rights and the constitutional balance of power. He may occupy the White House, but he does not own the country.AND THEN, THERE IS IMPEACHMENTThe House of Representatives does not need a two-thirds majority to impeach a president. A simple majority is sufficient to approve articles of impeachment. The matter then proceeds to the Senate, where conviction and removal require a two-thirds vote of senators present. The Constitution identifies treason, bribery and other high crimes and misdemeanors as grounds for impeachment. These are not limited to ordinary criminal offences. Serious abuses of presidential power, corruption, obstruction and attacks on constitutional government can potentially fall within that framework, depending on the evidence.There is, however, a critical difference: vetoing legislation is a constitutional presidential power. Even a president who uses that power recklessly or repeatedly is not automatically committing an impeachable offence. Democrats would have to establish evidence of serious misconduct, not simply political disagreement. Trump has already been impeached twice, in 2019 and 2021, and acquitted by the Senate on both occasions. Any future effort must therefore be built on documented facts and a compelling constitutional case, not political theatre.That is precisely why the incoming Democratic majority should approach its responsibilities with discipline. It should establish serious oversight investigations into corruption, conflicts of interest, government contracts, abuse of executive authority and possible obstruction of congressional scrutiny. It should advance legislation on healthcare, prescription drug prices, workers' rights and economic security. And whenever Trump vetoes a measure, Democrats should make the decision visible to the American public. Let voters see what was proposed, what was rejected and whose interests were served.There is a political calculation Trump may be missing. Every veto is also a public position. If Congress passes a measure protecting healthcare coverage and the president rejects it, he must defend that decision. If lawmakers propose measures to reduce prescription costs and he blocks them, he must explain why. A veto can stop a bill from becoming law, but it cannot erase the debate or silence the people affected by the decision. The more frequently he uses the power, the more responsibility he assumes for the consequences.The United States is a republic, not a one-man veto machine. The Constitution created separate branches of government precisely to prevent one individual from treating public authority as personal property. Congress is not the president's legislative department, and its members are not employees waiting for instructions from the Oval Office. They represent the people, exercise independent constitutional powers and have an obligation to defend the institution in which they serve.Trump may spend the next two years and one month reaching for his veto pen. Congress should spend that time doing its job, and the states should do theirs. Investigate where necessary, legislate where possible, challenge abuses of power and use impeachment if the evidence justifies it. The presidency is powerful, but it is not sovereign. And the Constitution was never written to give any president the final word on everything.
No comments:
Post a Comment